Astute Payroll Review: A Better Alternative?
An honest comparison of Astute Payroll and Accountee. Discover why growing businesses and recruitment agencies are choosing our boutique service model with Big 4 expertise at 60% lower cost.
Book a 15-minute chat with our team. No obligation.
About Astute Payroll
Astute Payroll, now powered by Deel, is a comprehensive workforce management platform designed for Australian businesses. The platform offers a full suite of payroll services including employee onboarding, timesheet management, payroll processing, compliance reporting, and integrations with popular accounting and recruitment software.
With features like configurable pay conditions for awards and EBAs, automated PAYG and payroll tax calculations, and STP compliance, Astute Payroll is built to handle complex payroll requirements. The platform also offers managed payroll services, where their in-house team can handle the entire payroll process on your behalf.
Astute Payroll is particularly popular among recruitment agencies and staffing firms due to its robust invoicing capabilities, contractor payroll features, and integrations with applicant tracking systems like Bullhorn and JobAdder.
What Astute Payroll Does Well
Astute Payroll has several strengths that make it a solid choice
Comprehensive Features
Extensive feature set covering payroll, timesheets, onboarding, compliance, and invoicing in one platform.
Strong Integrations
Connects seamlessly with Xero, MYOB, Bullhorn, JobAdder, and other popular business systems.
Compliance Management
Robust handling of STP reporting, SuperStream, awards, EBAs, and complex pay conditions.
Managed Services
Option to outsource your entire payroll function to their experienced in-house team.
Deel Partnership
Backed by Deel's global infrastructure and resources, providing enterprise-level support.
Industry Focus
Particularly strong for recruitment agencies and staffing firms with specialized features.
How Accountee Compares
A different approach to payroll and accounting services
Smaller, More Dedicated Team
While Astute offers enterprise-scale operations, Accountee provides a boutique service model with dedicated teams who learn your business inside and out. You're not just a ticket number—you have a named bookkeeper and accountant who know your history, understand your challenges, and provide proactive advice. This personalized approach means faster response times and better outcomes.
Superior Customer Communication
Accountee's smaller size is our competitive advantage. We respond faster, communicate more proactively, and build genuine relationships with our clients. Our ex-Big 4 Australian management team is directly involved in client service, ensuring you always have access to senior expertise. You won't get lost in a large organization or wait days for responses to urgent questions.
Significantly Better Pricing
Accountee's payroll services start at just $4 per person/pay run plus a simple retainer. This is typically 40-60% less expensive than Astute's enterprise pricing model. We achieve this through our efficient offshore-onshore model, not by cutting corners on quality. You get the same compliance standards and professional expertise, but at a fraction of the cost. For growing businesses watching their budget, this difference is substantial.
Ex-Big 4 Australian Management
Our leadership team comes from BDO, NAB, and Westpac, bringing Big 4 standards to every engagement. Every piece of work is reviewed by Australian accountants who understand local compliance requirements and business practices. This ensures you get enterprise-quality service with the personal touch of a boutique firm.
Focused Specialization
Like Astute, we specialize in recruitment agencies and growing businesses. But our smaller size allows us to go deeper with each client. We don't just process your payroll—we become strategic partners who understand your business model, growth plans, and unique challenges. This focused approach delivers better advice and more valuable insights.
Which Solution Is Right for You?
Choose Astute Payroll If:
- You're a large organization needing enterprise-scale infrastructure
- You require extensive software integrations across multiple systems
- You prefer a self-service software platform with training
- Budget is less of a concern than comprehensive features
- You value the backing of a global company like Deel
Choose Accountee If:
- You want a dedicated team that knows your business personally
- Superior customer communication and fast response times matter
- You need Big 4 quality at 40-60% lower cost
- You're a recruitment agency or growing business seeking strategic advice
- You value relationship-driven service over software features
Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know about Astute Payroll and alternatives
Experience the Accountee Difference
Get Big 4 expertise, dedicated teams, and superior customer service at a fraction of the cost. Book a free consultation to see how we compare.